Review: ‘Oscar Wilde and the Candlelit Murders (Oscar Wilde Mysteries 1)’ by Gyles Brandreth

Oscar Wilde and the Candlelight Murders: Oscar Wilde Mystery: 1 by [Brandreth, Gyles]

I’m a bit of an Oscar Wilder groupie, and enjoy Sherlock Holmes stories, so when I came across this mashup I decided to give it a whirl.

Brandreth is very knowledgeable about Oscar Wilde. He has written biographies about Wilde and his wider circle (and other well thought of biographies as well). So, factually speaking, he knows whereof he writes.

But how is he with plotting murder mysteries, I hear you ask.

The fun Brandreth had writing this first of an ongoing series (currently six) is evident throughout. The murder mystery does play second fiddle to Brandreth’s Wilde-isms as recorded by this book’s version of a Dr Watson, Robert Sherward.

Sherward was a real person, although what sort of relationship he actually had with Wilde we cannot know. There is nothing to suggest he was ever Wilde’s assistant in the way he is used in this book. Conan Doyle was, of course, also a real person. And he is embarking on his Sherlock Holmes series at the time this first book is set. He is basing Holmes on … you guessed it! His very clever friend Oscar Wilde.

The book is about Oscar Wilde through and through, despite making Wilde out to be the blueprint for Sherlock Holmes, despite the atmospheric Victorian murder mystery, Wilde is all. So if you are a fan of Oscar Wilde you are very likely to enjoy it (and the rest of the series). Even if you aren’t enormously into Victorian murder mysteries it is still fun.

I found it slightly irksome that Brandreth seems determined to attribute Wilde’s homosexuality (or perhaps dual sexuality) to a pure love of beauty, gender unspecified. He does actually use the quote about ‘the love that dare not speak its name’, the meaning of which I don’t believe is open to any other interpretation than ‘gay’ love (I use quote marks only because ‘gay’ in Victorian times was not used to mean homosexual). In order to lay down his own authorial words about the word ‘gay’ not being in vogue in Victorian society, and to look ahead to Wilde’s final three years in Paris, Brandreth freely steps through the gauzey curtain of his fiction and speaks directly on the reader. This need to unsuspend disbelief (!?) I found rather heavyhanded.

Nevertheless if you, like me, enjoy Conan Doyle’s Holmes and Watson stories, and, like me, have a weakness for Oscar Wilde you will find much to enjoy in this novel and its sequels.

At the end Brandreth gives potted biographies of the main players in his novel (all of which were real people). He also gives one of himself. These I found very helpful. They show exactly where the story has come from, and why.


Published by Judi Moore

Hi there, I hope you find something to interest you here. In December 2017 I published my fourth book – ‘Wonders will never cease’. It’s a satirical campus novel set in the fictional Ariel University in 1985. If you enjoyed Tom Sharpe’s Porterhouse novels, Willy Russell’s ‘Educating Rita’, David Lodge’s campus novels or Malcolm Bradbury’s ‘The History Man’ back in the day, you may enjoy revisiting the ivory towers of 1980s’ academe thirty years on. See what you think. “It is December, 1985. The year is winding gently towards its close until Fergus Girvan, a Classicist at Ariel University, finds his research has been stolen by the man who is also seeking to steal his daughter. But which man is, actually, the more unscrupulous of the two? And is there hope for either of them?” In the autumn of 2015 I published a volume of short fiction: 'Ice Cold Passion and other stories'. I am also the author of novella 'Little Mouse', a shortish piece of historical fiction which I published in 2014 and, a sequel to it, 'Is death really necessary?', my eco thriller set in the near future and which, confusingly, I published in 2009. All the books are available from all good online bookshops and FeedARead on paper, and as e-books on Kindle. On a semi-regular basis, and about a month after the event, I post here reviews which I do for Big Al & Pals, the premier reviewer of indie books, based in the States. My interests tend to thrillers, SF, magic realism and other quirky stuff. On this blog are also posted the reviews I did for Leighton Buzzard Music Club over some five years up to the end of 2015. LBMC present annual seasons of eight monthly chamber music concerts at the Library Theatre in Leighton Buzzard, Bucks. They select young musicians just beginning to make their name - and the concerts are usually magnificent. I was very proud to be associated with them. I review other music, books, theatre and exhibitions which I've particularly enjoyed. BTW - it says the link to Facebook is broken. I dispute that. Click it and see, why not?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: